First, let me say this is an amazingly realistic, well directed and well-acted war movie. Or should I say, "anti-war Movie". Unlike the fake "isn't war exciting" 1917, or the "rah, rah, lets kill those Krauts" Saving Private Ryan, this is a much more accurate and ADULT view of war. And I wish I'd seen it in the theater.
Having said that, the movie lacks what the 1929 version had in spades: Heart. We're always one step removed from the characters. The 1929 version made us deeply care about the characters. This one really doesn't. Another problem? It probably has a greater impact on young folks. I've seen a ton of anti-war movies, so the message didn't really reasonate with me.
Bottom line: I respect the film. It incredibly well-made. But it didn't hit me emotionally.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.